Producing Cleaner Markup

I'm not sure why my screenshots didn't attach on the post below this one. Sorry.

Either Word has changed or I'm missing something. When I change a single character in Word 365, I see a clean, one-letter change inside the word. [{fig}]
You can select less intrusive markup in Track Changes Options and Advanced Track Changes Options [{fig}].

Actually when I have to change/replace a letter in a word with Track Changes on, I make a point of selecting the target letter so that Word replaces the whole word. I want my clients to see my edits, and the single-letter replacement just isn't visible enough. So I do things the clumsy way, purely for visual effect.

As a lawyer editing and commenting on agreements, I find it useful to edit a copy of the document and then using the Review->Compare command create a fresh comparison to the original document. I almost never compare whitespace or formatting, but I always compare for case changes. Also, I often "clean up" the tracked changes to, for example, change a word-replacement to a letter replacement in cases like those pesky capitalization changes which often show up as a whole word change even though I always choose to do a "Character level" comparison.

An editor uses Track Changes to indicate to the author what changes have been made and let the author accept or reject the changes. This means that every change no matter how small must be shown, for example a comma changed to a colon or a comma added or deleted may change the meaning of the text. Apart from anything else, track change markups show that the editor has been thorough and have earned their fee.

The menu items in the Change Case button on the Home ribbon do not result in track change markups yet it can be important that the author know the case changes that have been made. The solution is to manually change the case by deleting and adding.

A change in formatting results in a balloon message and the page can become very cluttered with such messages. There is the option in the Show Markup menu to turn off the display of balloons but then there is no indication of format changes. Neither result is satisfactory. A workaround is to delete and add, then apply the correct format to the added text. For example to bold a word, first delete the word then re-enter the word and apply bolding.

I use macros to overcome the markup limitations in case changes and formatting.

To make accessing Track Changes even easier, you can add the Track Changes switch to the Status Bar at the bottom of the window. No need to keep switching back to the Review tab. Simply right-click on the Status Bar and select Track Changes. Click on it to turn Track Changes on and off. You can even see at a glance if Track Changes is currently on or off.

I agree wholeheartedly with turning off Track Changes to make small changes... and sometimes even certain large ones.

While working on a project with the Marine Corps, a couple of documents became corrupted, and the tracked changes seemed to be part of the problem. The documents had more than 1,200 tracked changes, from removing double spaces to changing "happy" to "glad" and back again to moving figures and/or tables multiple times. I told the Marine authors/reviewers to accept the small changes (e.g., spaces and punctuation, "a" to "an") as they went, and to turn off Track Changes when moving figures or tables to different parts of the document. (I had them put comments in the losing area to indicate a table/figure had been moved.) We didn't have any more corruption problems.

At my current job, I tell people to turn off Track Changes before generating/updating the TOC, as well.

Thanks for the tip to produce cleaner markup, Allen. I’ll put that to good use.

Regarding turning Track Changes off and on again, I turn it off while copyediting for clients mainly for two reasons:

* when selecting all text and changing the language [e.g., to English (AUS) or English (UK)]; leaving tracking turned on for this often results in huge numbers of changes being recorded, as if a language change is recorded for every change of style

* when changing non-breaking spaces introduced by authors copying and pasting text from websites to standard spaces; clients don’t need to see these changes—most probably wouldn’t understand their significance.

I’ve learnt to be REALLY careful to turn Track Changes back on again!

Every so often I get this extremely annoying glitch (in Word for Mac 2011) where Track Changes turns itself off. For that reason I keep the Review tab of the Ribbon displayed as much of the time as possible so I can keep an eye out for the work of the gremlins.